Guest Blog: Essayist Maureen Stanton on Why Insight is the Last Thing to Come

November 18th, 2009 by bakerkline

For this writer, the creative process happens in stages - and the final one makes all the difference:

Stanton essayThe first is the molecular stage, that early collection of bits of information, what I find fascinating, unusual, funny or poignant at the time it occurs, whether I retain it in memory or in a physical form on pieces of paper.

The critical mass stage is next.  The particles are vibrating on their own in proximity to one another until they reach a critical mass and a reaction occurs.  The writing begins in a fury, raw data, raw memory, stream of consciousness writing.

Incubation happens throughout the writing when I walk away from the piece and it sits inside me, silently arranging itself, so that when I next visit it, I have made important connections. Then I edit and rewrite.  The placement of events and observations creates irony, mood, pathos, humor.  Events are taken out of the chronological or random order and purposefully placed, refined, commented on.  Incubation can happen over a period of months or years, but also during the active writing periods, each night when I turn off my computer and go to bed with an essay on my mind. This seems important, that the essay is written only partially at the desk.  Much of it is written while I garden or walk or lay in bed mulling it over.

Insight is the last thing to come, what the story is really about. I often don’t know until very late in the process, and the story is frequently about something other than I intended, if I let the piece take the path it wants.  The telling phrases, observations, and reflections I add at this stage give the narrative facts a luminescence that only distance and learning can yield.  I can look with relative detachment at my experience and see it for what it really was, and in subtle ways, infuse these small epiphanies into the essay.

Distance.  Perspective.  It can take years to learn how an experience has sculpted me, to tell the story, to locate its pulsing heart.

Editor’s note: I discovered these observations in Stanton’s essay, “On Writing ‘Zion,’” in The Fourth Genre: Contemporary Writers of/on Creative Nonfiction, which I'm using in a creative nonfiction class at Fordham. Stanton’s insights were so helpful to my students that I asked her for permission to adapt them here – something I normally don’t do.

Maureen Stanton’s essays have also appeared in Creative Nonfiction, Iowa Review, and American Literary Review, among other places. Three of her essays were listed as "Notable Essays" in Best American Essays; her work has received a Pushcart Prize, the Mary Roberts Rinehart Award in Creative Nonfiction, The Penelope Niven Award in Creative Nonfiction, and The Iowa Review Award in Creative Nonfiction, among other prizes.  She has twice received an Individual Artist grant from the Maine Arts Commission, and a 2006 National Endowment for the Arts Literature Fellowship, and grants from the Vogelstein Fund and the Barbara Deming Memorial Fund.  She teaches creative nonfiction writing at the University of Missouri.

Line Break
Tagged as: , , , , ,
Line Break
  • http://www.lisaromeo.blogspot.com Lisa Romeo

    She really nails something important in her last line --
    "It can take years to learn how an experience has sculpted me, to tell the story, to locate its pulsing heart."

    This is so true, and often, so very hard to accept -- that we can't really write a great essay about what happened last week or month or sometimes even last year.

    I'm often surprised, when I finally do decide to write a particular essay, to open a file and see that my scratched out notes on little slips of paper are SO old (I tend to stick a date on everything). Can it really be that long ago that this happened, and that I first started to think about writing of it?

    Great post - thanks.

  • Bonnie Friedman

    So incredibly useful! Thank you. Am going to print this out for my own students! This is the best blog (and your novel, Christina, is KNOCKING ME OUT!!!!! I'm at the part where I have to read very slowly to make it last. How do you know so much about life, Christina?)

  • http://birdsandwords.wordpress.com birdsandwords

    Thanks so much for posting this! Maureen is one of my favorite nonfiction writers -- a good friend from the University of Missouri, where I used to teach. By the way, your blog is absolutely great! Thanks for sharing so much awesome insight re: writing/creativity etc.

  • http://www.christinabakerkline.com bakerkline

    Thanks so much for writing. I love Maureen Stanton's writing, too. I've taught her essays in my classes.

Line Break
Line Break